Pilchard or Round Sardinella: how to tell them apart
The two fish next to each other, fact by fact.
How to tell them apart
The Pilchard has fine ridges spreading like a fan on the gill cover and often a row of dark spots along the side. The Round Sardinella has a smooth gill cover, a faint golden line along the body and grows larger. The Round Sardinella also has more bones.
Scientific name
Pilchard
Sardina pilchardus
Round Sardinella
Sardinella aurita
Also known as
Pilchard
Sardela
Round Sardinella
Frissa, Triritsa, Sardelomana
Is it eaten?
Pilchard
Yes
Round Sardinella
Yes
Is it dangerous?
Pilchard
No
Round Sardinella
No
Usual size
Pilchard
10 to 15 cm
Round Sardinella
15 to 25 cm
Fishing season
Pilchard
May to October
Round Sardinella
June to October
Category
Pilchard
Pelagic & Open Sea Fish
Round Sardinella
Pelagic & Open Sea Fish
Conservation status
Pilchard
Least Concern (LC)
Round Sardinella
Least Concern (LC)
What it looks like
Pilchard
The European Pilchard, which is also widely known as the Sardine, is undoubtedly the most iconic small pelagic fish of the Mediterranean. It is a foundation species in the marine ecosystem, serving as a primary food source for countless predators and a nutritional treasure for humans. It is famous for its rich flavour and high content of Omega-3 fatty acids.
Round Sardinella
The Round Sardinella, which is also commonly referred to as the Spanish Sardine or the Gilt Sardine, is one of the most common small pelagic fish of the Mediterranean. Although it is often sold alongside sardines or confused with them, it is a separate species with its own characteristics. The body is elongated and laterally compressed with a blue-green colour on the back and silver on the sides.
Where it lives
Pilchard
This is a purely pelagic species that lives in the open sea. It forms massive, dense schools that can consist of thousands or even millions of individuals, which move in synchrony to confuse predators. It exhibits strong vertical migration behaviour. During the day, it descends to greater depths, usually between 25 and 55 metres, though it can reach 100 metres for safety.
Round Sardinella
This is a purely pelagic species that lives in large schools which move constantly. It prefers warm waters and is more abundant in the Southern Mediterranean. It is encountered at depths ranging from the surface down to 350 metres. It exhibits strong daily vertical migration, remaining in deeper waters for protection during the day and rising en masse to the surface at night to feed.
Everything about Pilchard Everything about Round Sardinella
More fish that get mixed up
- Albacore or Atlantic Bluefin Tuna
- Albacore or Little Tunny
- Anchovy or Pilchard
- Angular Roughshark or Spiny Dogfish
- Atlantic Bonito or Little Tunny
- Atlantic Mackerel or Chub Mackerel
- Blue Runner or Horse Mackerel
- Blue Whiting or Hake
- Brill or Turbot
- Broadtail Shortfin Squid or Squid
- Brown Comber or Comber
- Comber or Painted Comber
- Conger or Eel
- Dogtooth Grouper or White Grouper
- Dogtooth Grouper or Wreckfish
- Dusky Grouper or Mottled Grouper
- Flying Fish or Flying Gurnard
- Garfish or Halfbeak
- Greater Amberjack or Leerfish
- Mediterranean Spearfish or Swordfish
- Nursehound or Small spotted Catshark
- Red Mullet or Striped Red Mullet
- Stingray or Thornback Ray
Pilchard
Round Sardinella